Marley Was Dead…..I LOVE, LOVE, LOVE! that line.
Two of my favorite Christmas movies are The Muppet Christmas Carol and Scrooged with Bill Murray. Yes, I just put felt puppets and 1980s corporate nihilism on the same theological shelf. Stay with me.
One has singing rats and Michael Caine delivering Shakespearean gravitas to a frog. The other has a cynical TV executive getting punched in the soul by Christmas ghosts while being chased by a deranged fairy with a toaster. Both work because A Christmas Carol works.
It works because Dickens starts the story the way Scripture often starts reality: “Marley was dead.” Not sick. Not struggling. Not “going through a season.” Dead. Capital D. Toe-tagged. Buried. Pushing daisies. Dickens doesn’t ease us in with tinsel and cocoa. He drops a corpse on the table and says, Look at it. Because resurrection stories only matter if death is real.
Which makes it fitting, almost uncomfortable, that we treat this story like cozy Christmas wallpaper, when it’s actually a theological gut punch wrapped in chains and judgment. If we’re honest, that opening line sounds far more biblical than Hallmark ever dared.
Because the first Christmas didn’t happen in a snow globe. It happened under a paranoid king who murdered babies to protect his power. The Bible does not introduce joy gently. It introduces joy after darkness has had its say. And A Christmas Carol follows that same brutal honesty, because hospitality, real hospitality, doesn’t begin in comfort. It begins in confrontation.
Charles Dickens didn’t write A Christmas Carol because he loved Christmas lights or wanted to sell greeting-card sentiment. He didn’t sit down with a mug of wassail and think, You know what the world needs? More cozy. He wrote it because he was angry. He wrote it because England in 1843 was rotting from the inside out, and everyone with power was pretending the smell was progress.
This was the Industrial Revolution at full boil. Cities were swollen like infected wounds. Factories didn’t just make goods, they ate people. Men worked until their bodies quit. Women were replaceable. Children were cheap, small-fingered labor units. The poor weren’t seen as neighbors; they were obstacles, eyesores, inefficiencies in the march toward profit. And wealth, real wealth, had mastered the art of distance. Distance from suffering. Distance from consequence. Distance from responsibility.
Sound familiar? Yeah. Me too.
Christmas, in that world, hadn’t disappeared, it had been defanged. It existed either as stiff religious obligation, drained of life and neighbor-love, or as chaotic excess where people drank themselves into forgetfulness and called it celebration. It had lost its teeth. Lost its spine. Lost its ability to confront anyone about anything that actually mattered. It was holy on paper and hollow in practice.
Dickens saw debtors’ prisons with his own eyes. He watched families starve while factory owners congratulated themselves for “efficiency.” He lived in a culture that could quote Scripture fluently while stepping clean over the poor body lying in the road, careful not to wrinkle their coat. So Dickens did what prophets have always done when sermons stop working.
He wrote a story sharp enough to get past the guards. He didn’t stand on a street corner and yell. He didn’t write a theological treatise. He didn’t wag his finger. He told the truth sideways. And the truth he told was devastatingly simple: A society that refuses hospitality is already dead.
Because if we’re honest, painfully honest, the parallels aren’t subtle anymore. Many churches today look an awful lot like Dickens’ England with a cross slapped on the front.
They are bloated.
They are branded.
They are polished.
They are efficient. And they are quietly devouring bodies.
Not always physically, though spiritual burnout has a way of wrecking the nervous system just as effectively, but emotionally, spiritually, relationally. People are consumed for platform growth, volunteer numbers, giving goals, social media reach, and the never-ending hunger of more.
More campuses.
More influence.
More relevance.
More control. Meanwhile, the wounded are managed, not healed. The poor are discussed, not known. The broken are “discipled” right out the back door if they take too long to heal. And just like Dickens’ world, the most dangerous thing isn’t outright cruelty. It’s distance.
Distance disguised as leadership. Distance disguised as “healthy boundaries.” Distance disguised as “protecting the vision.” We’ve learned how to quote Scripture while stepping over people, very carefully, so as not to interrupt the service flow.
We’ve perfected systems that replace compassion. Policies that replace presence. Platforms that replace people. And when someone finally says, “Hey… something feels wrong here,” the answer is often the ecclesial version of Scrooge’s line: “Are there no programs? Are there no counselors? Are there no small groups?” Translation: Why are you bringing this to me? Isn’t there a system for that?
Just like in Dickens’ day, Christmas in much of the modern church has become either: Stiff religious obligation Show up. Sit down. Behave. Sing the song. Don’t ask hard questions. Drunken folk chaos (the sanctified version) Fog machines. Emotional manipulation. Spiritual sugar highs that wear off by December 26.
Neither requires hospitality.
Neither demands repentance.
Neither costs the institution anything.
And that’s the problem. Because Christmas, real Christmas, has always been a moral intervention. God did not enter the world gently. He entered it confrontationally. A baby born to poor parents. No room in the inn. A king panicking so hard about losing power that he slaughtered children.
That is not a backdrop for nostalgia. That is a judgment on systems that value power over people. And when the church forgets that, when it sanitizes Christmas into pageantry and playlists, it becomes complicit in the very thing Dickens was furious about.
The Church doesn’t need better marketing…It needs ghosts…well people Ghost. Dickens understood something we desperately avoid: Sometimes people don’t need encouragement. They need interruption. The church today loves to be the Cratchits, warm, smiling, inspirational. What it desperately lacks is: Marleys willing to warn. Ghosts willing to confront. Leaders willing to lose approval to save souls
We have too many Scrooges in leadership who are praised for efficiency and insulated from consequence. And worse, we canonize them. We excuse abuse because of “how many people it looks like are getting saved.” We overlook greed because “the mission is growing.” We silence whistleblowers in the name of unity, which is usually just comfort wearing a Bible verse. Dickens wrote A Christmas Carol because polite conversation had failed. Maybe that’s where we are again.
Here’s the part we don’t like: Calling a system to repentance is not being unloving. It is biblical hospitality. Hospitality doesn’t just set tables, it opens eyes. It doesn’t just welcome guests, it confronts hosts who have forgotten why the house exists. Dickens loved people too much to let them sleepwalk into damnation with clean hands and empty hearts. And if the church is honest, many of us need the same ghostly knock at the door. Not to shame us, but to save us.
Because the truth Dickens told still stands, sharper than ever: A society that refuses hospitality is already dead. And a church that consumes people in the name of Jesus, while ignoring the poor, silencing the wounded, and protecting its own wealth and platform, may still be breathing……but it’s rattling chains it doesn’t want to hear yet.
The question isn’t whether the church needs a moral intervention. The question is whether we’ll listen before Marley’s dead weight is all that’s left to speak.
Ebenezer Scrooge isn’t evil in the cartoon sense. He’s not twirling a mustache. He’s not burning villages. He’s worse. He’s efficient. He’s the kind of man who believes he’s done nothing wrong because he’s followed the rules, paid his taxes, and kept to himself. Scrooge doesn’t stab anyone. He just refuses to make room. And biblically speaking, that’s enough.
If hospitality is about making space, for God, for others, for interruption, then Scrooge is a man who has boarded up every window of his soul.
He hoards:
Warmth
Time
Money
Compassion
Joy
His fire is small. His office is cold. His heart is locked. When asked to give to the poor, his response isn’t ignorance, it’s theology: “Are there no prisons? Are there no workhouses?” That is Romans 12:13 reversed and weaponized. “Share with the Lord’s people who are in need. Practice hospitality.”
Scrooge doesn’t practice hospitality. He practices distance. He believes systems replace compassion. That charity is optional. That responsibility ends at the edge of personal comfort. And here’s the uncomfortable truth: Scrooge is not an outlier. He is a mirror.
Jacob Marley doesn’t show up as a bad guy even most churches I have gone to in the south would label him as such if he came a spoke to the pastor. He shows up as a warning label. Bound in chains he forged himself, cash boxes, keys, ledgers, Marley is what happens when a man realizes too late that life was not meant to be lived alone. And this is where everyone gets it wrong. We’re always told: “Don’t be a Scrooge.” “Be generous like Scrooge after he changes.” “Have a Cratchit heart.” All true. All incomplete.
Because the unsung calling of the Church is not just to be redeemed Scrooges. It’s to be Marleys who warn while there’s still time. Marley’s tragedy isn’t that he’s punished. It’s that he can no longer act. He sees clearly now, but cannot practice hospitality anymore. And that should terrify us. Because Scripture is relentless on this point: Knowledge without action is judgment, not maturity. Marley’s ghost exists to say: “Do not wait until your chains are set.”
Now the Ghosts. They are not gentle….But… They’re hospitable in the hard way. The ghosts don’t knock. They don’t RSVP. They don’t care about Scrooge’s sleep schedule or emotional readiness. They force entry. Which, frankly, is biblical. God rarely waits until we feel ready to change.
He shows up to Abraham unannounced. Jesus invites Himself to Zacchaeus’ house. The risen Christ walks through locked doors. Hospitality in Scripture is not about comfort. It’s about interruption.
The Ghosts of Christmas are not sentimental guides. They are active participants in another man’s redemption. And that’s the model we’ve forgotten. We want changed people, but not involvement. We want testimony but not process. We want miracles but not mess. The Ghosts do not stand at a distance and hope Scrooge figures it out.
They walk him through memory. They confront him with consequence. They show him suffering with faces attached. They practice the hospitality of truth.
Look at the Cratchits. They do not have enough of… well anything. That’s the point. Their table is small. Their meal is modest. Their future is uncertain. And yet they practice hospitality instinctively. They don’t debate generosity. They don’t form committees. They don’t wait for financial security. They live Romans 12:13 because they have to. “Share with the Lord’s people who are in need. Practice hospitality.” Hospitality, here, is not an event. It’s a reflex.
Their home is warm because love lives there. Not money. Scrooge has abundance and eats alone. The Cratchits have little and feast together. That is biblical economics. Tiny Tim Is Not Cute, He’s Christological. Tiny Tim is not Dickens being sentimental. He is Dickens being theological. Tim is the vulnerable neighbor Scripture will not let us ignore.
He is:
Sick
Dependent
Powerless
Unable to repay kindness
Which makes him dangerous. Because how we treat the vulnerable reveals who we are actually welcoming. Jesus doesn’t say: “Whatever you did for the deserving…” He says: “Whatever you did for the least of these…” Tiny Tim is Matthew 25 with a limp. And Scrooge’s soul is measured by whether Tim lives or dies. Because hospitality is never abstract. It always has a face.
When Scrooge wakes up changed, notice what he doesn’t do. He doesn’t journal his feelings. He doesn’t issue a carefully worded apology. He doesn’t sign up for a seminar or “start the work.” He opens his life.
He gives.
He feeds.
He goes.
He joins.
He restores.
That’s Luke 19 repentance. “I will give back four times the amount.” Scrooge and Zacchaeus are spiritual twins. Repentance that doesn’t cost you anything isn’t repentance, it’s regret. Hospitality is repentance with proof.
Here’s the unavoidable end of all this: Christmas itself is the ultimate act of hospitality. “Though He was rich, yet for your sake He became poor…” (2 Corinthians 8:9) God didn’t save us from a distance. He came near. He entered our poverty. He slept in our mess. He knocked, and waited to be welcomed. And the backdrop was brutal. A king murdered babies to protect his power.
Christmas was born in blood, fear, and political violence. Which means joy has always been an act of resistance. Hospitality has always been defiance. Be dangerous with love.
So no! Don’t just be a Cratchit. And don’t just be post-redemption Scrooge. Be Marley while there’s still time. Be the Ghosts who refuse to stay distant. Be the kind of people who take responsibility for the souls around them. Practice the hospitality of interruption. The hospitality of truth. The hospitality of walking with someone through change. Because the end goal isn’t better Christmas vibes. The end goal is ultimate Joy.
A table wide enough for repentance. A door open enough for grace. A life that points, relentlessly, to the One who came near. Jesus Christ. The reason for the season. The Host who became the Guest, so we could finally come home. And if Christ has truly been welcomed into your house, your house will never stay closed.
Stay Salty & Burn Bright




